• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (10)
  •  

Energy minister presents look at Muskrat Falls power project

Deputy minister Murray Coolican provided an overview of the Muskrat Falls/Maritime Link project that the NDP government believes is the best option for Nova Scotia future power needs. They believe it will stabilize power prices and offer a more environmentally friendly energy source. ADAM MACINNIS – THE NEWS

Deputy minister Murray Coolican provided an overview of the Muskrat Falls/Maritime Link project that the NDP government believes is the best option for Nova Scotia future power needs. They believe it will stabilize power prices and offer a more...

Published on March 18, 2013
Published on March 18, 2013
Adam MacInnis  RSS Feed
Topics :
Department of Energy , NDP , Muskrat Falls/Maritime Link , Muskrat Falls , STELLARTON , Trenton

STELLARTON – The province is moving in a direction that will eventually see the coal-powered Nova Scotia Power Plant in Trenton closed and more renewable energy powering Pictou County homes.

Business people, municipal leaders and opposition party members were in attendance Monday as Energy Minister Charlie Parker spoke in Stellarton about the direction the province is moving with regards to electricity.

"We know that rising electricity rates are top of mind for everyone," said Parker. "We are not going to sit back and do nothing to address the issue. We are taking action that will make a real difference."

He said the province has already removed the provincial portion of the HST from basic home electricity and talked about the renewable energy projects in this area already including several large wind projects.

"We're very pleased to be creating the right conditions for these investments," he said. "These projects will help stabilize electricity prices in Nova Scotia and benefit the environment."

Parker and Department of Energy deputy minister Murray Coolican also provided information and an overview of the Muskrat Falls/Maritime Link project.

The project will provide Nova Scotians with a reliable source of clean energy at predictable, stable rates for 35 years. They hired a consultant and, based on the research they got back, believe it is the lowest long-term cost option for the province to meet federal environmental requirements. It will give the province a second connection to the North American electricity grid and therefore more options for purchasing energy in the future.

The Muskrat Falls hydroelectric project has been approved by the province but still needs to be reviewed by the Utility Review Board. Parker said there will be a decision from them by July whether it is the way to go and what the rate should be.

Parker said the Nova Scotia’s contributions to the Maritime Link will see the average homeowners power bill raise about $1.50 a month for the next five years, but stated his belief that it was the best option.

Parker stressed the importance of the province getting off of “dirty coal.”

“This province has depended for far too long on coal,” he said.

That will mean that the plant in Trenton will likely close.  

“There’s no particular date in mind, but we do know that plant will be phased out,” he said.

There is also the possibility that it could be converted to another type of energy form, however.

With several opposition party members in the room, Parker defended the province’s approach and said that the opposition’s proposal that rates should be freezed wasn’t practical.

While none of the Progressive Conservative candidates spoke during the meeting, Pictou East candidate Tim Houston offered his thoughts afterward.

Houston agreed it was important to look at ways to diversify the province's power supply, but said he has concerns about the NDP pushing forward with the Muskrat Falls project without doing its homework.

"Nova Scotians can't afford for the NDP to get this wrong,” he said. “We still don't know how much this electricity will cost when it reaches our homes and businesses and it has not been fairly compared to all alternatives.”

Houston said he agrees with an attendee who wondered how the government could say this project will bring us rate stability for 35 years when it will only provide eight to 10 per cent of overall consumption. 

"The NDP is pushing headlong into a deal that our kids will have to live with and just because the project has merits, doesn’t mean the NDP signed a good deal for Nova Scotians."

Parker is travelling throughout the province to spread information about the energy plan.

Comments

  • Username
    To nothing is free...again...lol
    - March 22, 2013 at 00:41:12

    Do you know that Nova Scotia Power currently inports power through NB, from Maine, New Brunswick and Hydro-Quebec? The transmission tarriffs are already set and Nova Scotia has transmission rights in NB. Trouble is those rights are being signed over to Nalcor Energy as part of the Maritime link deal eating up our capicity to import via NB. If for some reason Nalcor can't move 300MW to or through NB then NS is required to purchase the difference, on top of the 155MW Nova Scotia block. NS Power has approval to aquire right of ways for a second transmission line to NB. Who do you think will end up paying for that when they build it? The Ratepayers? In NS we pay 13.79 ¢/kWh, Hydro-quebec charges their customers: First 30 kWh/day 5.32 ¢/kWh on Remaining energy consumption 7.51 ¢/kWh. 30 kWh/day x 30 days=900 kWh per month from Nova Scotia Power you will pay $124.11 while Hydro-Quebec customers would pay $47.88. And after 35 years ownership of the Maritime Link will revert back to Nalcor Energy for $1. There is a lot of bad for us in the Maritime Link deal. The more I research it the more it worries me. Once we're in, we're all in. We better get it right.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Gasman
    - March 20, 2013 at 08:11:59

    Well Nothing is free Coal is still by far the most cost effective way to generate BASE Load. Green Energy does not provide base load. Carbon taxes are not about the environment but rather another socialist tax grab for governments that indeed have spending problems. Carbon Trading is indeed BS as well. Now saying Coal is the most cost effective does not mean I believe we should be burning coal. Natural Gas is the least harmful way of getting the required base load which in Nova Scotia is about 2000 Megawatts. In Regards to NS and Pei not having access to Hydro and Nuclear that is not exactly true. New Brunswick has a newly renovated Nuclear plant inwhich they sell surplus energy to the state of Maine. Considering the state of the US Dollar It may be indeed more attractive to sell that energy to PEI or Nova Scotia. The newest part of the Trenton plant is no wheres near the end of life. It would be entirely feasible to convert to natural gas that flows about 17 miles away via a partially emera owned pipeline. Then there is the onshore exploration that will come after the NDP is thrown out of office. Fracking is coming to Nova Scotia which would allow us to be energy independent.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      nothing is free
      - March 20, 2013 at 17:35:12

      I agree, coal is cheap... right now. But I think it's going to be priced much higher very soon. I don't care much for wind/green as it has a lot to be proven but I think more natural gas generation would be a good thing. I still don't know why a lateral pipeline isn't built up the East River from Lorne to Trenton, Abercrombie and Granton. I would think that NSP, North Nova Pulp and Michelin would provide a good demand. Point Lepreau is an option for off-setting our coal and PEI gets 15% or more of its load from that plant but there are only 650 MW there. The big dams in Quebec are spilling that much or more in excess capacity some days...

  • Username
    pictou county
    - March 19, 2013 at 18:51:11

    Good to see that Pictou county will loose hundreds of well paying jobs. You guys do good work ndp. You better not be commin to my house at election time. Start fighting for jobs other then building boats...

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Alan J
    - March 19, 2013 at 13:46:10

    You forgot to mention Charlie, that when your NDP "took of the HST", you quietly renamed it "Efficiency" and added it back on to the power bills. Now you want to close another local business throwing hundreds out of work, and we shall see the power and gas bills skyrocket with your "green dream". Count on it folks!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Didn't Vote For Them
    - March 19, 2013 at 07:55:12

    Pictou County's three muskateers seem to be everywhere in the news lately but they continue to skirt the topic that many voters in Pictou County really want to talk about. When are they going to call an election?

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Being Fooled
    - March 19, 2013 at 00:22:14

    $1.50/Month X490,000 NS Power customers =$735,000 X 12 months = $8,800,000 X 5 years=$44,000,000 paid on $1.5B Maritime Link investment, where does rest come from? Well the "Maritime link cost recovery regulations" states: "Once approved under Section 5, an applicant is entitled to recover Project costs through a rate, toll, charge or other compensation from Nova Scotia Power Incorporated in accordance with Section 8" So they will tell us $1.50 a month, then rates will have to rise to pay off the $1.5 billion link cost, the total with interest will be around $4.5 billion.. A huge price to pay for 8-10% of the total power needs of the province. I think someone has the wool pulled over the governments eyes. Who could that be.......I wonder?

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      nothing is free
      - March 19, 2013 at 12:24:37

      All of our coal power plants are reaching the end of their life. The USA is soon going to introduce carbon trading and possibly even a carbon tax. Canada will likely follow suit immediately. Alberta and BC currently charge a carbon tax so it's only a matter of time before Ottawa does. Every other province except for NS and PEI have access to either hydro or nuclear which won't be affected by carbon taxing/trading. We are extremely vulnerable to a massive, painful, almost knee chopping, price hike in electricity. I used to live in the Northwest Territories where we paid 30 cents a kilowatt hour. That was tough but we had good jobs. That could be the reality in NS if we don't get off coal. I don't blame the NDP or any other party for the situation we find ourselves in. Nova Scotia made the best decisions it could at the time when they were made. However, the world is moving on and time is ticking on these plants so it is good that at least we have an option with Muskrat Falls. I don't like the price tag and the risk involving the Maritime Link but if Quebec is not willing to move Newfoundland and Labrador's hydro from Muskrat Falls to us cheaply, then this is our only other option. Either that or we build a nuclear power plant. Or Ottawa steps in and says to Quebec that they can't overcharge for wheeling power through their province from Muskrat Falls to us.

    • Username
      To Nothing is free
      - March 19, 2013 at 20:54:37

      Do you realize that Maritime link will replace very little coal fired generation. Maritime link is a 500MW subsea cable. The Nova Scotia block of guaranteed power is 155MW. Nalcor owns the transmission rights to the balance of the cable capacity and the NS transmission rights through NB. NS transmission line upgrades will be carried out to allow Nalcor to export their block to the USA. The NS coal generator capacity level is currently 1252MW. So our 155MW portion of Maritime link will leave us with 1097MW of in province coal fired plant capacity that is reaching the end of life. Expect huge future costs to replace them at end of life and to meet the legislated emmissions targets. As far as Hydro-Quebec is concerned, I think someone should ask them to qoute a price. We can't know what they have to offer until we ask. It has been reported that the state of Vermont signed a long term deal with Hydro-Quebec, their current rate is $58MW while Maritime link starts at $120MW in 2017 and rises to $180MW in 9 years.

    • Username
      nothing is free
      - March 20, 2013 at 17:29:55

      I agree, Hydro Quebec transmission lines are only 350 km from Amherst so it would be a no-brainer to ask them for a quote. Or is NB going to charge us a huge mark-up just like Quebec did to Newfoundland with the Upper Churchill back in the 60s? To me the Muskrat Falls project is nothing but a Danny Williams vanity project and Danny ''Millions'' and Nalcor suckered in Dexter and Emera with this Maritime Link business. There are a pair of sub-sea cables running from NB to PEI and they have failed on a few occasions. And that is shallow water which allows for easy repairs. I don't think the geography of the Cabot Strait allows for that.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

Advertising