Past to present: Pictou Landing residents remember swimming in Boat Harbour

Amanda Jess
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

As Sarah Clark returned from a trip from Moncton last week, she rolled down her window when she reached Pictou Landing to tell the protestors she would be joining them soon. 

Roderick Francis was among more than a dozen residents who used to swim in Boat Harbour. He said there are only five of them remaining. 

The 58-year-old began to cry when it hit her that there was no smell from Northern Pulp.

“I never thought I’d see that day again,” she said, adding that she last smelled fresh air in Pictou County in the 1960’s.

When the mill was running last week, before a broken effluent pipeline forced it to close, the odor was a pale comparison to when the kraft pulp mill first opened, under the ownership of Scott Paper, she said.

She remembers seeing buildings turn black and paint peeling off homes.

“If it’s affecting buildings that way, what is it doing to our lungs?” she asked while on site of the blockade at Indian Cross Point.

She and others, including Roderick Francis, used to swim at A’Se’K, also known as Boat Harbour, as children in the late 1960’s.

Francis said they were told by the government of the day that it was safe to swim.

Clark noticed it was black, but figured if others were in it, then it must be okay.

It wasn’t until she noticed eels coming to shore that she began to question it.

“If fish are running from it, there must be something wrong,” she thought at age 12.

They were also eating berries and apples along the road leading up to the beach, digging for clams and fishing.

Eventually, they all stopped swimming there, as well as another local beach, one that was as popular as Melmerby Beach is now, as the water began to change colour, she said.

“There’s only four or five of us left that swam in that effluent,” Francis, 59, said, adding that there had been 10 others who had also played in the water.

Scott Paper began discussions in 1964 about building a mill at Abercrombie Point with the agreement that the province would provide a place to put the wastewater after it was used in the pulping process.

It started operating in 1967.

Almost ten years later, Pictou Landing First Nation took action against the federal government for inaction in the community’s best interests.

In 1991, the federal government starts negotiations for a settlement. In the same year, the province promised to close Boat Harbour as a treatment facility after the wastewater agreement with Scott Paper expired in 1995.

“I heard it very often. When the PCs (Progressive Conservatives) were in power, I heard it every month,” Francis, a former band chief, said about how many times he heard Boat Harbour would be cleaned.

Clark left a few years after the mill was established in 1975, moving to Massachusetts, and ended up working in a paper mill.

She came back in the early 1990’s after her husband passed and her mother was sick.

By 1993, an agreement was reached out of court, promising $35 million in compensation.

The Scott Paper agreement ran out in 1995, but no alternative site for wastewater had been chosen, with the province extending the timeline to close Boat Harbour by 2005.

The mill transferred hands twice over the next 10 years and possible solutions were deemed unfeasible, prompting another extension to 2008.

During this time, Clark was researching what was coming out of pulp mills while she was studying at Nova Scotia Community College. She did a presentation on it in 2006, explaining the bleaching process.

In 2008, the province agreed to extend the license on a month-to-month basis. The mill was transferred to Northern Pulp, and the province asked the community to let it go, and said they wouldn’t extend it beyond Dec. 31 without consultation. However, by November, they told the province they would not agree to any more extensions.

An election halted meetings with a negotiator and new government officials asked for more time to examine the issues.

In September 2010, a lawsuit was filed against the province and Northern Pulp, following a lack of change after a request from Pictou Landing asking the province to end the license by June 30, 2010.

Since then, the permit has continually been renewed, during which time Northern Pulp was acquired by Paper Excellence and a Facebook group pushing for a cleaner mill started gaining traction.

On Twitter: @NGNewsAmanda

Organizations: Nova Scotia Community College, Scott Paper

Geographic location: Boat Harbour, Northern Pulp, Pictou County Massachusetts

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

    June 16, 2014 - 13:55

    If you hate paper mills so much then stop using toilet paper, kleenex, paper towels and medical gauze.

  • Ex-Pictou county resident
    June 16, 2014 - 12:27

    Nslover you seem to hate on the Liberals quite a bit, since McNeil got into power he closed down several NDP programs that were a waste of money exposed quite a bit of corruption within and also has put the NSEMU in their place which needed to be done years ago. I am 26 years old and visited home for the first time in half a year when I was driving down into the landing I couldn't believe my surprise when it was fresh air I was smelling and not something that smelt like burnt used toilet paper. I say shut down the mill until they pay their dues, repair the damage they've done AND THEN force them to bring it up to code before allowing it to turn on for even one single day!

  • StellartonExpat
    June 16, 2014 - 09:33

    This reads like the mill should take legal action against the provincial government for not upholding their agreement. If this crisis shuts the mill it's clearly the fault of this and past NS governments inaction.

  • Great Representation
    June 16, 2014 - 07:59

    The local MLA in his blogs writes "Dear Diary: My heart is heavy for those that depend on the mill. I am sure they are feeling under attack. That is just wrong. All they want is to do their job. Yet they have been let down by successive mill owners that have chosen not to be good neighbours and the governments that have enabled them. Many of the mill employees are close personal friends to all of us and my friends know (I hope) that I certainly don't want the mill to close." Mr. Houston, perhaps you were off earning your tax-free salary in Burmuda when your party, the PCs were part of the problem you describe. You should have more concern for the residents in the area who are affected by this pollution. Instead you feel sorry for your close personal friends. Congratulations. You are now a true politician. You made it, Bud!

  • Nslover
    June 15, 2014 - 16:44

    McNeil should follow through on the promise HIS PARTY that HE RAN FOR made in the 1990s. Either he believes what he says, remember he ran the last election on trust, or he is a lair. I bet is the later but maybe McNeil is different so far he seems to be worse then any leader we have ever had. There is still time though for him to turn this around and make it right.